The United States government has recognized
that repetitive-stress injuries represent a
major source of pain and disability for office
and factory workers. The most common repetitive-stress
injury to the upper extremity is Carpal Tunnel
Syndrome (CTS). In a study of all claims accepted
by the US Department of Labor, Office of Workers'
Compensation Programs (OWCP), from 1993 through
1994, CTS was one of the most costly diagnoses
and represented the highest in expenditures
for surgical services [1]. Although the study
indicated that while CTS represented a relatively
small percentage of all workers' compensation
cases, the health care and indemnity costs were
considerable. The Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA) is now prepared to require
employers to install ergonomics programs to
help minimize and prevent these injuries. With
the advent of home computers, more people are
experiencing this repetitive-stress injury during
their personal time, too. Untreated CTS can
result in prolonged symptoms of pain and disability
and permanent nerve damage. Find out what CTS
is, how it is diagnosed, what the possible causes
are, and what can be done for prevention and
treatment in this article.
What
is Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS) is a compression
of the median nerve in the carpal tunnel of
the wrist. If you turn your palm up and look
at your wrist, you can see and feel some of
the flexor tendons of the wrist and fingers
as they cross over the carpal tunnel. The tunnel
actually contains nine tendons that are involved
in flexing the wrist and fingers, as well as
the median nerve. A thick ligament called the
transverse carpal ligament or flexor retinaculum
forms the top of the tunnel and covers the tendons
on the palm side of the hand and the carpal
bones of the hand form the bottom of the tunnel.
When the wrist is in a neutral position or straight,
the most room for the tendons exists. However,
when the wrist is flexed (held downward), the
space decreases and there is more potential
for nerve compression. When the median nerve
is compressed by the transverse carpal ligament,
it causes the signs and symptoms of CTS.
Signs,
Symptoms, and Diagnosis
The signs and symptoms of CTS are numbness,
tingling, and pain in the thumb, index, middle,
and half of the ring finger, weak thumb movements,
and weakness in rotating the hand palm down
(pronation) or in flexing the wrist [2]. Patients
usually complain of pain at night and of dropping
things. There are two prominent clinical tests
that are performed to help determine a CTS diagnosis.
Phalen’s test is positive if tingling
of the fingers is felt when the hands are pressed
together for more than sixty seconds while they
are both flexed downward [3]. A Tinel's sign
is exhibited when tapping over the tunnel results
in tingling throughout the median nerve distribution.
Electromyography and nerve conduction velocity
tests are also used to help verify a CTS diagnosis.
What
Causes Carpal Tunnel Syndrome?
There are many reasons why the median nerve
gets compressed in the carpal tunnel. One common
cause of CTS is overuse or cumulative trauma.
Constant wrist flexion, repetitive wrist flexion
and extension, along with wrist rotation and
finger flexion (gripping) can cause tendinitis
(inflammation) of the flexor tendons. This chronic
swelling can lead to a fibrosis or thickening
of the transverse carpal ligament. One study
of 352 workers from three different companies
showed that repetitiveness of work was found
to be significantly associated with a prevalence
of reported discomfort in the wrist, hand, or
fingers and a strong association with carpal
tunnel syndrome [4]. Improper workstation set-up,
asymmetrical task performance, and repetition
without rest breaks can also contribute to cumulative
trauma. Sports and recreational activities that
can lead to CTS are lacrosse, gymnastics, cycling,
throwing sports, racquet sports, knitting, needlepoint,
piano playing, cooking, computer games, and
typing, to name a few. Even serious weightlifters
whose muscles hypertrophy (enlarge) and take
up too much space in the carpal tunnel could
be at risk [5]. CTS can also be related to systemic
medical illnesses like diabetes, hypothyroidism,
and rheumatoid arthritis. Acute trauma, where
the wrist is hit and the contents of the carpal
tunnel are injured, can be a cause of CTS. In
addition, several cases have been made for CTS
originating from congenital defects, wrist shape,
and pregnancy. There have been studies to show
that obesity may be related statistically to
CTS [6]. And sometimes, there is no known cause,
as in idiopathic CTS.
Treatment
Typical conservative treatment involves modalities
like ice and ultrasound to decrease inflammation.
Avoiding gripping or pinching activities, especially
with the wrist flexed, and wearing a splint
can calm down tendinitis. Stretching and strengthening
the wrist and finger flexors and extensors when
the acute phase is over and performing nerve
and tendon glide exercises are part of a physical
therapy protocol
As far as pharmacological and surgical interventions
go, conservative treatment with drugs is attempted
first before a surgical carpal tunnel release
is performed. Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
medications are sometimes prescribed, but oral
corticosteroids have shown to be more effective
[7]. A single injection with steroids close
to the carpal tunnel may result in long term
improvement and should be considered before
surgical decompression [8].
Alternative medicine has shown some promise
in treating CTS. A yoga-based regimen was found
more effective than wrist splinting or no treatment
in relieving some symptoms and signs of carpal
tunnel syndrome [9]. The yoga consisted of 11
yoga postures designed for strengthening, stretching,
and balancing each joint in the upper body along
with relaxation given twice weekly for 8 weeks.
With regards to acupuncture, even the National
Institute of Health (NIH) believes that acupuncture
may be useful as an adjunct treatment to be
included in a comprehensive management program
or as an acceptable alternative.
In reviewing 12 years of CTS outcomes, researchers
concluded that the limited evidence available
indicated: 1) steroid injections and oral use
of B6 were associated with pain reduction; 2)
in comparison to splinting, range of motion
exercises appeared to be associated with less
pain and fewer days to return to work; 3) cognitive
behavior therapy yielded reductions in pain,
anxiety, and depression; and, 4) multidisciplinary
occupational rehabilitation was associated with
a higher percentage of chronic cases returning
to work. They also lamented that despite the
emerging evidence that the cause of CTS is multifactorial,
the majority of outcome studies have focused
on only on single interventions directed at
individual factors [10].
Prevention
Prevention can be as simple as good strength
and flexibility and monitoring repetitive wrist
motions and gripping activities. Research has
suggested that reducing the duration, frequency,
or intensity of exposure to forceful repetitive
work, extreme wrist postures, and vibration
is likely to result in a reduction of the incidence
or severity of CTS in working populations [11].
Ergonomics or the way a workstation is designed
can be of significant importance. Proper positioning
of furniture (like desks and chairs) and equipment
(like computers) will result in correct posture
and placement of the wrists during typing. The
wrists should be straight and even, not bent
up or down. Using different geometric keyboards
or ergonomically designed mice can decrease
the chance of CTS [12]. Taking frequent rest
breaks and developing consistent work/rest cycles,
where during the rest cycle some type of stretching
movement is performed, can also help prevent
CTS.
References
1. Feuerstein, M., et al., Occupational upper
extremity disorders in the federal workforce.
Prevalence, health care expenditures, and patterns
of work disability. J Occup Environ Med, 1998.
40(6): p. 546-555.
2. Tortora, G.J. and S.R. Grabowski, Principles
of Anatomy and Physiology. Eighth ed. 1996,
New York: HarperCollins College Publishers.
380.
3. Phalen, G.S., The carpal-tunnel syndrome.
Clinical evaluation of 598 hands. Clin Orthop,
1972. 83: p. 29-40.
4. Latko, W.A., et al., Cross-sectional study
of the relationship between repetitive work
and the prevalence of upper limb musculoskeletal
disorders. Am J Ind Med, 1999. 36(2): p. 248-259.
5. Weinstein, S.M. and S.A. Herring, Nerve problems
and compartment syndromes in the hand, wrist,
and forearm. Clin Sports Med, 1992. 11(1): p.
161-188.
6. Lam, N. and A. Thurston, Association of obesity,
gender, age and occupation with carpal tunnel
syndrome. Aust N Z J Surg, 1998. 68(3): p. 190-193.
7. Chang, M.H., et al., Oral drug of choice
in carpal tunnel syndrome. Neurology, 1998.
51(2): p. 390-393.
8. Dammers, J.W., M.M. Veering, and M. Vermeulen,
Injection with methylprednisolone proximal to
the carpal tunnel: randomised double blind trial
[In Process Citation]. Bmj, 1999. 319(7214):
p. 884-886.
9. Garfinkel, M.S., et al., Yoga-based intervention
for carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomized trial
[see comments]. Jama, 1998. 280(18): p. 1601-1603.
10. Feuerstein, M., et al., Clinical management
of carpal tunnel syndrome: a 12-year review
of outcomes. Am J Ind Med, 1999. 35(3): p. 232-245.
11. Viikari-Juntura, E. and B. Silverstein,
Role of physical load factors in carpal tunnel
syndrome. Scand J Work Environ Health, 1999.
25(3): p. 163-185.
12. Tittiranonda, P., et al., Effect of four
computer keyboards in computer users with upper
extremity musculoskeletal disorders. Am J Ind
Med, 1999. 35(6): p. 647-661.
|