|
Stop popping pills, sitting in warm baths, and
resting on the couch to treat your aching body.
Doctors and scientists are now preaching the
benefits of exercise to treat arthritis. The
creaking joints, pain with bending, squatting,
or stairclimbing, and difficulty buttoning clothes
are all symptoms of one of the most debilitating
diseases today. Either you, a family member,
or a friend has some form of arthritis. Osteoarthritis
(OA) affects more than 21 million Americans,
according to the American College of Rheumatology.
Learn how you can decrease pain, stop the progression
of the disease, and improve your functional
capacity by adding moderate aerobic, resistance,
and flexibility exercises to your daily routine.
What
is Osteoarthritis?
There are over 100 different forms of arthritis,
but OA, which used to be called degenerative
joint disease, is the most common. It can affect
children, but most often affects middle-aged
and older people. Women are generally affected
at a younger age and are more likely to have
painful symptoms than men [1, 2]. OA involves
degeneration of cartilage on the ends of bones
that form joints like in the neck, lower back,
knees, hips, and fingers, but the joint most
commonly reported with symptoms and disability
is the knee [2]. Cartilage is a protective spongy
material that acts as a shock absorber to keep
bones from rubbing together. The joint is enclosed
in a capsule of tissue called the synovium.
The synovium's lining releases a slippery fluid
that nourishes the joint and helps it move smoothly.
Ligaments, muscles, and tendons support the
joint for movement and balance. As the cartilage
is damaged, the bone and surrounding structures
break down as well. This causes the typical
OA symptoms of inflammation, pain, stiffness,
crepitus (creaking), and deformity. It is these
symptoms that lead to inactivity and decreased
functional capacity in those with OA.
Risk
Factors
Some of the risk factors associated with OA
can be avoided. Much literature supports a definite
link between obesity and knee OA. The Framingham
Osteoarthitis Study showed that weight loss
reduced the risk for symptomatic knee OA in
women [2]. In fact, this study showed that just
a 10 pound decrease resulted in a 50% reduction
in the odds of developing knee OA. In subjects
that already had OA, weight loss reduced their
joint pain. Repetitive trauma, like that experienced
in elite and professional athletes, has also
been shown to be a preventable risk factor.
Previous injury to a joint, a joint that has
been subjected to prolonged heavy use, or a
joint damaged by prior infection or inflammatory
arthritis is at risk for OA. Unfortunately,
age is an OA risk factor that is not preventable
[2]. The good news is that habitual physical
activity like household, job, and leisure activities
in the middle-age years do not increase the
risk for OA [3].
How
OA Affects Your Body
The symptoms of OA such as pain, decreased range
of motion (ROM), and instability all lead to
a decrease in functional capacity. Functional
capacity is the body’s ability to perform
at its optimum level and a decrease is seen
in decreased VO2 max (oxygen consumption per
minute), decreased muscular strength, decreased
flexibility, and decreased ability to perform
activities of daily living. When OA sufferers
are in pain, they typically rest. This leads
to less compressive forces on bones and muscles.
It is these compressive forces that move the
synovial fluid in the joints around for lubrication
and distribution of nutrients. Also, inactivity
results in weak and atrophied muscles. A study
that involved strengthening the quadriceps muscle
of knee OA patients found that reduced functional
capacity is due to reduced muscle function [4].
OA
Management
The goals of managing OA are to control pain,
minimize disability, and educate the patient
and family [5]. Pain management can be handled
pharmacologically with aspirin-free pain relievers
like acetaminophen and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
drugs like ibruprofen. Corticosteroids are sometimes
prescribed by doctors to reduce severe pain
and swelling. Surgery is an option for severe
cases when all other methods have failed.
Non-pharmacological management includes the
use of modalities like heat or cold, joint protection
techniques like avoiding prolonged standing,
kneeling and squatting, assistive devices like
canes and walkers, proper shoes and orthotics,
and exercise. The American College of Rheumatology
published guidelines for the treatment of knee
OA that suggest that exercise be one of the
mainstays of OA treatment [5].
Exercise
and OA
It has been said “exercise may be the
most effective, malleable, and inexpensive modality
available to achieve optimal outcomes for people
with OA” [6]. A study on a group of 120
patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and
OA showed that a 12-week program of aquatics
and land walking improved aerobic capacity,
50-foot walking time, depression, anxiety, and
overall physical activity more than in a control
group that only performed ROM exercises [7].
A surprising finding to this study at a nine-month
follow-up showed that the control group also
had a significant increase in aerobic capacity.
Researchers concluded that this was due to approximately
70% of the control group continuing to exercise
and performing more conditioning-type exercises
than just ROM. It turns out that the ROM control
group got “hooked” on exercise and
wanted to continue reaping the benefits. Still,
many OA patients are afraid that exercise will
increase their symptoms. But, supervised fitness
walking and patient education can improve functional
status without worsening pain or exacerbating
arthritis-related symptoms in patients with
osteoarthritis of the knee [8]. A study that
divided subjects into a strength training group,
an endurance training group, and a combination
group, found that joint symptoms varied over
time in all groups, but were unrelated to exercise
[9]. Additionally, no major injuries occurred
in this study. Still another study demonstrated
that moderate intensity aerobic and resistance
exercise reduced pain and disability, improved
physical fitness, and did not exacerbate symptoms
in people with knee OA [10].
Types
of Appropriate Exercise
Now that we know exercise is beneficial for
OA sufferers, what kind of exercise is recommended?
Ideally, every exercise program should be individualized
and approved by your doctor. Some common treatment
goals are to increase strength, joint ROM, muscular
flexibility, endurance, and function, and to
decrease pain and protect joints from further
damage [6]. This can be accomplished by resistance
and aerobic exercise and stretching.
Resistance exercises increase or maintain muscle
strength and tone. Strong muscles stabilize
your joint, allow easier movement, and improve
balance. You can start resistance exercises
by performing simple isometrics and then progress
to isotonics. Isometrics are exercises where
the joint does not move, but the muscles surrounding
the joint are tightened, held for about 10 seconds,
then relaxed. An example is quadsetting, where
the straight leg is supported on a flat surface
and the quadriceps muscle, the muscle on the
top of the thigh, is contracted. Eventually,
full ROM isotonic exercises can be added.
Aerobic exercise, or endurance exercise, is
as simple as walking. Start slowly and build
your endurance up for a goal of 20 to 30 minutes,
three times a week.
Flexibility exercises are types of stretching
exercises that can increase joint ROM. You can
also perform ROM exercises just by flexing and
extending the joint and moving them in a circular
motion.
How
to exercise
Plan your exercises sessions when you have less
stiffness or pain, for example, in the afternoon,
rather than the morning. It is important to
start slowly and build up the amount of time
you exercise and the number of repetitions you
do. Let pain be your guide. If you are experiencing
pain with exercise, then the exercise isn’t
appropriate for you. If you have pain after
exercising, remember to decrease the intensity
or length for the next session. Stop exercising
immediately if you have chest pains, severe
dizziness or shortness of breath. Incorporate
water and land exercises to receive the unloading
benefits of water, as well as the weightbearing
benefits of land.
A total body warm-up should be performed first
to increase the blood flow to all of your muscles
and prepare your body for exercise. This can
be as simple as walking in place with high knees
and simultaneously swinging the arms. A period
of flexibility and ROM activities should follow
with every muscle stretched 2-3 times and held
for 30 seconds to 1 minute, unless contraindicated
because the muscle surrounds an unstable joint.
Aerobic exercise can follow next and then a
resistance or weight training component can
be added or performed on another day. A 3-to-5
minute cool-down period can include slow walking
and focus on additional flexibility and breathing
and relaxation techniques. Although one side
of your body may be weaker or have a more significant
amount of arthritis, you should exercise the
entire body to achieve the maximum benefits
of exercise [4]. To improve or maintain fitness,
exercise must be performed regularly and appropriate
exercise habits must be maintained [7].
Summing
Up the Benefits of Exercise for OA
All forms of exercise will assist you with your
weight loss goals and anytime a joint is moved
the synovial fluid will lubricate and feed the
joint. Research studies have shown that exercise
does not increase OA symptoms and can even decrease
the risk of further OA development. A program
of flexibility and strengthening improves muscle
function, exercise capacity, and functional
performance [11]. Exercise helps reduce pain
and keeps you active, so get off the couch and
get to work!
For more information, exercise programs, support
groups and other help, visit the American College
of Rheumatology website at www.rheumatology.org
or The Arthritis Foundation website at www.arthritis.org.
References
1. Davis, M., et al., Knee osteoarthritis and
physical functioning: evidence from the NHANES
1 epidemiologic followup study. J Rheumatol,
1991. 18(4): p. 591-8.
2. Felson, D., et al., The prevalence of knee
osteoarthritis in the elderly: The Framingham
Study. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 1987. 30(8):
p. 914-18.
3. Hannan, M.T., David T. Felson, Jennifer J.
Anderson and Allan Naimark, Habitual Physical
Activity is Not Associated with Knee Osteoarthritis:
The Framingham Study. Journal of Rheumatology,
1993. 20(4): p. 704-709.
4. Fisher, N., et al., Muscle rehabilitation:
its effect on muscular and functional performance
of patients with knee osteoarthritis. Arch Phys
Med Rehabil, 1991. 72: p. 367-74.
5. Hochberg, M.C., et al., Guidelines for the
medical management of osteoarthritis. Part II.
Osteoarthritis of the knee.American College
of Rheumatology [see comments]. Arthritis Rheum,
1995. 38(11): p. 1541-6.
6. Minor, M.A., Exercise in the treatment of
osteoarthritis. Rheum Dis Clin North Am, 1999.
25(2): p. 397-415, viii.
7. Minor, M.A., et al., Efficacy of physical
conditioning exercise in patients with rheumatoid
arthritis and osteoarthritis. Arthritis Rheum,
1989. 32(11): p. 1396-405.
8. Kovar, P., et al., Supervised fitness walking
in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee.
Annals of Internal Medicine, 1992. 116(7): p.
529-34.
9. Coleman, E.A., et al., The relationship of
joint symptoms with exercise performance in
older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc, 1996. 44(1):
p. 14-21.
10. Ettinger, W.H., Jr., et al., A randomized
trial comparing aerobic exercise and resistance
exercise with a health education program in
older adults with knee osteoarthritis. The Fitness
Arthritis and Seniors Trial (FAST) [see comments].
Jama, 1997. 277(1): p. 25-31.
11. Fisher, N. and D. Pendergast, Effects of
a muscle exercise program on exercise capacity
in subjects with osteoarthritis. Arch Phys Med
Rehabil, 1994. 75: p. 792-7.
|